A constructivist conception of legal interpretation
نویسندگان
چکیده
This essay explores a number of issues central to value-based yet positivist conception law and legal interpretation. In particular, after some reflections on whether in what sense theory can be considered axiologically and/or methodologically superior, classic the interpretation are discussed: distinctions noetic versus dianoetic interpretation, interpretatio legis iuris, simple difficult cases. The analysis then focuses claim correctness inherent reasoning, its pragmatic connotations, controversial relations thesis so-called separation morality, ethical conformism. I argue that proposed by Isabel Lifante is instead non-neutral contributes reinforcement Dionysian Herculean practice.
منابع مشابه
A New Conception of Legal Insanity
ions are not at all that different from the personifications of the fairy tale" (p. 75). Statements about crazy behavior that ascribe agency to intrapsychic entities such as "impulses" or "internal pressures" are homologous to statements that the insane are ruled by demons. The anthropomorphisms of the former mode of explanation are more subtle and use terms that sound mechanical and impersonal...
متن کاملInterpretation Across Legal Systems
In this paper we extend a formal framework presented in [6] to model reasoning across legal systems. In particular, we propose a logical system that encompasses the various interpretative interactions occurring between legal systems in the context of private international law. This is done by introducing meta-rules to reason with interpretive canons.
متن کاملA Logical Understanding of Legal Interpretation
If compliance with a norm does not achieve its purpose, then its applicability must dynamically be restricted or expanded. Legal interpretation is a mechanism from law allowing norms to be adapted to unforeseen situations. We model this mechanism for norms regulating computer systems by representing the purpose of norms by social goals and by revising the constitutive rules defining the applica...
متن کاملSpatial chromatic tessellation: conception, interpretation, and implication
A novel spatial tessellation scheme, spatial chromatic tessellation (SCT), is proposed for representing and exploring space– entity relationship. The objective of this article is briefly introducing the basic concepts, structure, and properties of SCT. Our study mainly focuses on the arranged chromatic diagram (ACD), which is the most typical type of SCT. A few examples show that ACD can be use...
متن کاملLegal Status of Treaties in Interpretation and Application of Article 7 of the Iranian Civil Code
Nowadays there are many aliens’ populations living in other countries. Forced Migration and Study of Religious Sciences are two main reasons introducing Iran as a host country. This paper Intends to clarify some questions about enforcement of Iranian civil code which determines the applicable law on the personal status of foreigners. There are some disagreements about the law governing personal...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Revus
سال: 2022
ISSN: ['1581-7652', '1855-7112']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/revus.8234